Clarivoy & study spots limitations of last-click attribution


Here’s another way store managers can measure how impactful — both from reach and cost perspectives — their online presence is.

Dealers using Google Analytics are now able to accurately attribute the value of third-party sites such as, according to the initial findings from a trial use of Clarivoy’s Multi-Touch Attribution solution.

In an April trial with, officials highlighted more than 100 dealer customers upgraded their Google Analytics platform with Clarivoy’s Multi-Touch Attribution solution. The Clarivoy solution is designed to help dealers understand how all their digital marketing investment efforts — not just the last click or interaction — influence the car buying journey.

The company indicated the initial use of Clarivoy’s solution revealed that Google Analytics misses the cost-effective conversion value of sites such as For instance, on average, dealers who implemented the multi-touch attribution solution saw conversions on their sites attributed to increase by 37 percent with a 20 percent decrease in cost after two months in the trial.

Clarivoy pointed out that the results were even more dramatic when dealers considered the conversions that occurred directly on The addition of data — leads, vehicle description pages (VDPs), and trackable walk-ins — to this multi-touch attribution model allowed one dealer to identify 11,390 conversion events that happened on the site in addition to the original 103 reported by Google Analytics.

According to Clarivoy chief executive officer Steve White, dealers typically rely on Google Analytics to help them understand the impact of their advertising. However, White insisted the true value of a third-party auto site doesn’t show up in Google Analytics as it is by default set up to give all of the credit to the last click.

“Typically, what we see is a lot of third-party websites do not get the credit they deserve because in most cases the last engagement that occurs with the dealer’s website is either branded search, organic or direct traffic,” White said. “As a result, sites such as become invisible to Google Analytics when trying to evaluate performance.

“Dealers needed a solution that helps them see the actual impact a partner like really brings and the ability to compare that to their other marketing channels in one dashboard,” he continued. chief revenue officer John Clavadetscher reacted to the trial findings, too.

“Time and time again, we see dealer customers overspending on paid search, because they are only measuring marketing impact based on the last click,” Clavadetscher said.

“By understanding the full customer journey leading up to the last click, dealers are able to better understand the influence that has on the path to purchase and make more informed decisions about how to allocate their marketing spend,” he went on to say.

When shopping online, many customers view a dealer’s VDPs or submit an inquiry right on the website, and this data is never reflected in Google Analytics. Clarivoy’s native integration can offer several benefits including:

• Clarivoy’s Attribution Channels classify data more logically and accurately specifically for dealers

• Dealers can apply cost data from all digital marketing investments to evaluate the true cost per engagement and cost per lead using Clarivoy's proprietary multi-touch attribution model

• Insight into conversion activity, including VDPs, lead submissions and Lot Insights data

“The biggest differentiator of our solution for dealers is our independent, unbiased approach for analyzing and reporting data. We don’t have a stake in the game,” White said.

Clarivoy’s Multi-Touch Sales Attribution platform can focus on user-level attribution, allowing dealers to transparently view a consumer’s full purchase path, sorting and ranking the influence of each channel’s contribution — paid search, display ads, TV, email, third-party websites, organic search, social and brand website — to understand what is really driving sales.

For a copy of the Clarivoy/ case study, go to this website

How marketers are tackling budget & format challenges

CARY, N.C. - 

No matter what size screen consumers might be seeing the promotional message, securing budget is the current biggest concern for automotive marketers, according to a recent study.

In today's ever-evolving digital landscape automotive marketers must capitalize on every opportunity online to engage shoppers to remain competitive, making it a challenge to decide which aspects of marketing to direct ad dollars.

As a result, 40 percent of auto marketers named securing budget as their top concern when asked by GetResponse for its recent study, Email Marketing and Beyond: Global Industry Benchmarks.

GetResponse created its research report in partnership with Holistic Email Marketing, an email marketing consultancy.

Their findings are based on a survey of 2,510 email marketers who belong to a range of industries.

The study also found that the automotive industry has one of the lowest click rates among the group of 18 different industries evaluated.

At 18 percent the average click rate reported by automotive marketers is the second to lowest, followed by the internet marketing at 13 percent.

The average click rate across each industry is 3.9 percent.

The auto industry is first when it comes to using automation, and travel marketers were found to use it the least.

Seventy-three percent of auto marketers say they do and just 46 percent of those in the travel industry.

Additionally, only 11.80 percent of marketers are using lead scoring and 17 percent of automotive marketers were found to.

Where to market?

The desktop is where the auto industry receives most of its traffic.

A total of 65 percent of the industry's traffic comes from desktops, according to a recent study by ContentSquare examining the user experience of customers.

The company’s study, "Solving the Automotive Industry’s Ecommerce Challenges," also suggests that marketers focus on visuals to engage consumers online. It found that of the shoppers it surveyed, 40 percent of them interact with the visuals on product pages.

For example, on pages with visuals about new technologies, they recorded traffic increased by 127 percent, according to the study.

While the desktop is important, the same shoppers also use their mobile devices to shop, so marketers must focus on winning the consumer mobile moments too says Dominion Dealer Solutions director of managed marketing services Amy Peck.

“Mobile has changed the way consumers search and shop, and has put a huge emphasis on local SEO, near me searches, for example.”

“In the automotive industry, a lot of time is spent talking about managing local SEO website, headers, tags and keywords. Often, dealers ignore areas that have a huge impact on their SEO.”

She said another thing to keep mind is how voice search will affect traffic. Online searchers via artificial intelligent virtual assistant devices such as Amazon Echo are becoming popular for consumers.

“Typically, voice searches are longer tail searches asking for more information. It is critical that a new or used-car dealership’s website content is conversational- always looking to answer questions consumers may have about the dealership,” Peck added. pinpoints most-searched used models in May


Thanks to a new patent from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, produced what the company said is a first-to-market solution that can pinpoint key mobile shopping data from consumers actively looking for vehicles on dealer lots nationwide.

Using Lot Insights technology, created the new On-the-Lot Trends Report by analyzing mobile consumer shopping behavior throughout the month of May to identify the top viewed makes and models by segment for both used and new vehicles.

First introduced in 2015, Lot Insights technology (Patent No. 9686646) can identify mobile consumers on or near dealership lots to provide valuable insights for automotive advertisers. The patented technology allows for more precise, accurate, location-based consumer data for dealer partners.

“While most digital companies are interested in clicks, likes or impressions, is focused on efficiently driving buyers into dealer showrooms,” chief executive officer Alex Vetter said.

“Mobile data intelligence, like Lot Insights, allows us to analyze those consumer behaviors and directly measure how digital activity impacts sales,” Vetter continued. “We have been at the forefront of the mobile revolution in our industry, and this new Lot Insights patent is an example of how is leading mobile innovation.” chief product officer Tony Zolla added, “By mapping and geofencing the perimeter around dealerships with this level of precision, we can better understand today’s shopping trends & behaviors, which is critical to making value-added connections between consumers and dealers.”

 Here are the top viewed lists for used and new vehicles searched that appears in the May report:

Used Luxury Vehicles:
1. Mercedes-Benz C-Class
2. Mercedes-Benz E-Class
3. BMW 328
4. BMW X5
5. Mercedes-Benz S-Class

Used Compact Sedans:
1. Honda Civic
2. Volkswagen Jetta
3. Toyota Corolla
4. Mazda Mazda3
5. Subaru Impreza

Used Midsize Sedans:
1. Honda Accord
2. Dodge Charger
3. Toyota Camry
4. Nissan Altima
5. Ford Fusion

Used Full-size Sedans:
1. Nissan Maxima
2. Chevrolet Impala
3. Chrysler 300
4. Ford Taurus
5. Toyota Avalon

Used Trucks:
1. Ford F-150
2. Chevrolet Silverado 1500
3. Toyota Tacoma
4. Toyota Tundra
5. Ford F-250

Used SUVs:
1. Jeep Grand Cherokee
2. Jeep Wrangler
3. Jeep Wrangler Unlimited
4. Ford Explorer
5. Chevrolet Tahoe
6. Toyota 4Runner

Used Luxury SUVs:
1. BMW X5
2. Acura MDX
3. Land Rover Range Rover
4. Land Rover Range Rover Sport
5. Porsche Cayenne

New Luxury Vehicles:
1. Porsche Panamera
2. Alfa Romeo Giulia
3. Land Rover Range Rover
4. Mercedes-Benz E-Class
5. Porsche Macan

New Trucks:
1. Ford F-150
2. Chevrolet Silverado 1500
3. RAM 1500
4. Toyota Tacoma
5. GMC Sierra 1500

New Compact Sedans:
1. Honda Civic
2. Hyundai Elantra
3. Volkswagen Jetta
4. Subaru WRX
5. Subaru Impreza

New Midsize Sedans:
1. Dodge Charger
2. Honda Accord
3. Toyota Camry
4. Ford Fusion
5. Hyundai Sonata

New Full-size Sedans:
1. Nissan Maxima
2. Chrysler 300
3. Chevrolet SS
4. Chevrolet Impala
5. Ford Taurus

New SUVs:
1. Jeep Grand Cherokee
2. Jeep Wrangler
3. Jeep Unlimited
4. Toyota 4Runner
5. Ford Explorer

New Luxury SUVs:
1. Land Rover Range Rover
2. Porsche Macan
3. Land Rover Range Rover Sport
4. Audi Q7
5. Porsche Cayenne

Holiday car shoppers are often ready to buy

CARY, N.C. - 

In the spirit of summer holidays like Independence Day, suggests that auto dealers align their pre-holiday advertising and mobile content in time for holiday weekends.

The third-party shopping site found that during holidays, car shoppers tend to buy — and they also want special offers delivered to their mobile phones.

Consider the traffic dealerships saw this Memorial Day weekend.

Over the Memorial Day weekend, 30 percent of mobile consumers surveyed purchased a car.

Roughly 71 percent of mobile consumers said they visited a dealer to specifically shop for a vehicle, and 26 percent for service, according to a recent Memorial Day Weekend survey on’s blog.

On a non-holiday weekend, 60 percent of consumers visit a dealer for service and 40 percent to shop.

When it comes to special offers via mobile, around six out of 10 shoppers told that they prefer “special offer” content shared with them on their mobile devices, while 81 percent of dealers prefer to share “why buy from us” mobile messaging, Research and Insights senior manager Amanda Kaleta-Kott explained.

Additionally, during the Memorial Day weekend, 41 percent of all store visits were walk-ins where the shopper didn’t contact the dealer prior to making a visit.

Twenty percent of those walk-in shoppers surveyed by bought a car over the holiday and seven out of 10 said they wish to make a purchase within three months.

For some used-car shoppers, 'Fly to Buy' makes most sense

CAMBRIDGE, Mass.  - 

While most of the time a used-car shopper isn’t going to stray far from home to buy a vehicle, in certain cases it actually makes more financial sense for them to take a flight to a city where car prices are considerably less expensive.

Or as CarGurus puts it, “Fly to Buy.”

Analysts with the company found that because of the way used-car prices differ across the country, flying to a city with significantly lower used-car prices can sometimes be a cheaper option for the consumer — even when travel costs are considered.

“Shopping local makes sense for most car shoppers, but the adventurous deal-seeker could find a used car far outside their home region and still see big savings — with the added bonus of a fun summer road trip,” CarGurus data analyst Lisa Rosenberg said in a news release.

“Even for less ambitious shoppers, this research highlights just how much variability can exist on used-car prices in different markets,” she said. “Expanding your search area even moderately can sometimes unearth opportunities to save.”

CarGurus gives the theoretical example of an Albany, N.Y. car shopper looking to buy a 2015 Ford Mustang.

If the shopper booked a one-way plane ticket to Miami to buy the car instead, then drove the car back to New York, he or she would save over $2,000.

And that includes fuel and plane costs.

Similarly, an Albuquerque, N.M., shopper can hop on a jet to Dallas and save $1,900 when he or she buys a 2007 BMW 3 Series.

And one trip CarGurus listed netted savings of more than $4,000.

If a shopper is willing to trek across the country from San Jose, Calif. to Buffalo, N.Y. to buy their 2014 Chevrolet Silverado, doing so could save $4,347.

If a Nashville Predators fan wants to commiserate with a Cleveland Cavaliers fan, flying from the Music City to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame will net a savings of $3,307 on a 2013 Ford F-150.

All told, CarGurus listed what it found to be the top Fly to Buy routes for popular vehicles, which include:

2007 Chevy Tahoe: Reno, Nev. to New York – estimated savings of $2,224

2013 Ford F-150: Nashville, Tenn. to Cleveland – estimated savings of $3,307

2014 Chevy Silverado: San Jose, Calif. to Buffalo, N.Y. – estimated savings of $4,347

2014 Chevy Silverado: Sacramento, Calif. to Boston – estimated savings of $3,036

2007 BMW 3 Series: Albuquerque, N.M. to Dallas – estimated savings of $1,871

2010 Chevy Camaro: Louisville, Ky. to Miami – estimated savings of $1,781

2006 Dodge Charger: Jackson, Miss. to Washington, D.C. – estimated savings of $1,392

2006 Dodge Charger: Memphis, Tenn. to Miami – estimated savings of $2,239

2007 Toyota Camry: El Paso, Texas to Chicago – estimated savings of $1,877

CarGurus determined the savings by taking Instant Market Value data on more than 5 million used cars in the Lower 48 states, determining the IMV on poplar used vehicles in each metro area, then comparing the various metro areas.

The savings account for average airfare costs based on U.S. Department of Transportation Domestic Airline Consumer Airfare Report from the third quarter of 2016; fuel costs based on AAA figures from June 5; and it defined metro areas as 50 miles around the center of a given city.

For more from CarGurus, check out our podcast below with chief revenue officer Sam Zales.


New CFO joins automotiveMastermind


automotiveMastermind has hired Eric Daniels as chief financial officer to reinforce a controlled financial infrastructure that provides product development opportunities within the company.

Daniels most recently served as the chief financial officer of National Response Corporation, a private equity owned environmental services company.

He brings 15 years of experience leading global finance teams of both middle-market private and public companies.

“Bringing in Eric is the right step toward building an executive team capable of making the right investment decisions and solidifying the responsible financial and legal systems of the company,” automotiveMastermind chief executive officer and co-founder Marco Schnabl said in a news release. “Innovation continues to be at the forefront of automotiveMastermind and these executive appointments will help the company grow in all aspects while supporting our current exponential growth.”

Daniels' background includes improving the operational efficiencies of companies in various industries and generating key indicator reporting to help drive growth.

He has managed acquisition integrations, financial system implementations and facilitated capital market transactions, according to automotiveMastermind.

“My previous experience has made me better able to identify a market leader and innovator like automotiveMastermind. The way the company utilizes data and passes it on to our dealer partners adds value and ROI that pays for itself four times over,” Daniels said.

“This kind of performance in the market will help us set the benchmark for how all automotive sales are transacted. The ultimate goal is to make the automotiveMastermind Behavior Prediction Score become as synonymous as a FICO score.”

VinSolutions to host summit on CRM utilization & retention

MISSION, Kan. - 

VinSolutions is set to host its annual VinWorx User Summit on July 11 and July 12 at the Sheraton Kansas City Hotel at Crown Center in Kansas City, Mo.

The two-day summit provides attendees training on improving CRM utilization and how to use data to increase customer retention. 

"Automotive and marketing trends are changing on an ongoing basis, coupled with a shifting sales forecast in automotive. For dealerships to stay ahead of their competition, they need to know how to create a personalized customer experience and how to maximize marketing, lead-generation and ongoing customer engagement," VinSolutions Senior Director of Performance Management Mark Vickery said in a news release. "VinWorx is the perfect setting for dealers to gain some new insights, skills and approaches to making their dealerships more profitable."

VinWorx speakers, break-out sessions and software training will focus on topics relevant to auto dealers, such as what dealerships can expect from the car selling process in today’s digital landscape.

Breakout sessions will cover three themes related to VinSolutions' Connect CRM: Connect, Ignite and Succeed.

The summit's line-up of keynote speakers includes Cox Automotive Chief Operating Officer Mark O'Neil; Tim Mueller, automotive industry strategist from Google; PCG Communications founder Brian Pasch; and Mike Burgiss, Cox Automotive’s vice president of digital retailing.

"We are always asked by our customers what can be done to make them better dealers," Vickery added. "At VinWorx, you can have that conversation with VinSolutions experts and your peers from across the country."

For more additional information about VinWorx or to register for the summit, click here.

Consumers show strong midsize sedan loyalty


Consumers’ loyalty to midsize sedans is currently strong and shopper interest across all luxury SUV/CUV segments is up 2 percent from April, according to Jumpstart Automotive Media’s latest shopper interest data report.

Interest in midsize sedans across Jumpstart’s portfolio of sites is up for the second consecutive month, rising by 4 percent during April and May.

Jumpstart’s May report determined 49 percent of midsize sedan shoppers surveyed by the company are exclusively researching vehicles in this category.

“As shopper interest in SUVs and CUVs has grown exponentially over the past few years, luxury auto brands have been expanding their lineups to include more size, feature, and pricepoint options. And we’re seeing that these brands are now experiencing broad audience appeal,” Jumpstart marketing and strategic insights vice president Libby Murad-Patel said in a news release.

“We are also interested to see that midsize sedans — a segment that had the fifth largest loyalty decrease in 2015 – 2016 (down 11 percent) — has seen loyalty grow every month this year. As loyalty continues to be a challenge, especially amidst the growth in SUV and CUV options, this is impressive.”

Behind Ford and Chevrolet, holding its rank as the third most-shopped brand, Toyota gained 6-percent share last month.

Toyota saw success among some of its core and newer models such as the Camry, RAV4 and C-HR.

Fellow Japanese brand, Mazda, also gained 6 percent share in May, the automaker currently ranks eighth among of all brands researched on Jumpstart sites.

The report broke down Toyota & Mazda growth trends in May:

  • Toyota

— Camry (+8%, rank 17)

— RAV4 (+16%, rank 32)

— Corolla (+15%, rank 55)

— C-HR (+89%, rank 104)

— 86 (+41%, rank 136)

— Yaris iA (+19%, rank 248)

  • Mazda

— CX-5 (+7%, rank 13)

— MX-5 Miata (+18%, rank 14)

— CX-9 (+20%, rank 26)

— 6 (+17%, rank 77)

— CX-3 (+4%, rank 85)

Jumpstart's May report is based on the shopping behavior of more than 17 million car shoppers who are researching vehicles across the company’s portfolio of automotive publishers.

CarStory revamps solution to keep mobile shoppers & ‘skimmers’ on VDPS

CARY, N.C. - 

CarStory has released an enhanced version of its Market Reports that is designed to heighten mobile shopper engagement on VDPs, according to the artificial intelligence platform’s creator Chad Bockius.

“The main focus for this release was all about the design, in terms of the look and feel, but more importantly how we represent the analytics that we share and how to optimize Market Reports for mobile shopping,” Bockius said in a phone interview with Auto Remarketing.

“Over three-fourths of consumers today are shopping on their mobile device — both on their couch and on the lot. And as a result of that, it has created a culture of skimmers.”

Because mobile devices have become the primary type of interface for a large majority of the population it is important to make mobile shopping experiences conveniently engaging, Bockius explained.

“They’re going to skim information quickly and we had to address that,” he said.

“We had to create an experience that allows consumers to access and consume the data the way that they want it. Which is just a reality of 2017.”

CarStory Market Reports is now fitted with added additional data elements, such as a feature on the Market Reports home screen where machine learning is used to automatically identify images, according to Bockius,

“Based on our research, we know exactly which images consumers want to see first, and we use that data and our machine learning to process those images to create a collage on the first screen of the Market Report. Which is not just a nice design element, but more importantly it’s giving information to the consumer,” Bockius explained. “It’s not giving them the information over text, it’s giving them information visually, so they can see what features the vehicle has.”

Bockius said CarStory offers dealers three benefits: more engagement, more leads and ultimately more sales.

“In our research, we have found that dealers who have employed Market Reports see a 60 percent decrease in bounce rate. And we have seen a 24 percent increase in lead conversion,” he said.

Bockius believes the dealer VDP should be the best resource for a consumer who is making that decision to buy.

“The more people that you are bringing into the door, the more you are going to be able to sell. If you can’t engage that consumer on the VDP, it’s the equivalent of having that consumer walk off your lot,” he said.

“We have brought all the critical research information directly to bare on the dealers’ VDP to keep those consumers engaged and tell the consumer the whole story, so that ultimately they can make that confident decision to buy.”

CarStory has the largest depository of inventory data in the industry, according to Bockius.

“It’s quite amazing, the amount of science and the amount of data processing that occurs to generate these reports, but at the end of the day our goal is to hide all that to ultimately create a simple summary that consumers can access right on that dealer VDP,” he said. “When we analyze the data, we are looking at a specific vehicle relative to the market competition in a local area. All of our data comes down to two buckets of data we have to sort and analyze the first is all of the market supply data or the actual inventory, so what is available for sale today — that’s part of the data.”

Bockius said consumer demand data, which covers a variety of things, is the second source of CarStory data.

“We look at what consumers are searching for, the vehicles that they are spending their time on, the vehicles they are cross shopping and the features they are looking for,” he added.

Bockius mentioned that Kevin Frye, eCommerce director of Jeff Wyler Automotive Family once told him that with CarStory Market Reports, he can become an instant expert on every car on the lot.

“You can imagine how difficult it is for any salesperson to know the specific, the whole story about hundreds of cars,” he said. "We automate that process for you, we can put that information right in your pocket and you can be an expert whether you’re talking to a consumer on the phone or on the lot instantly, and that is going to help dealers move metal,”

CarStory is completely free to dealers. For more information, about Market Reports or to become a participating dealer, visit

Florida Ford store involved with PERQ’s $25K promotion winner


PERQ — a service provider that says it has experts in online consumer engagement and behavior to help dealers — on Wednesday announced the winner of its annual $25,000 FATWIN Sweepstakes. The recipient was a customer who shopped online through a Florida Ford store’s website.

Jose M. Hervis Garcia from Plantation, Fla., was selected from more than 171,000 eligible FATWIN entries. Garcia, his wife and two sons plan to put the money toward a house.

“This is one of the best parts of my job — watching dealership customers deploy interactive website experiences that consumers are engaged in and get value from. We devised the $25K sweepstakes to incentivize the consistent provision of quality data by consumers – which translates into higher conversions for our dealership customers,” said Muhammad Yasin, director of marketing at PERQ.

“On behalf of the PERQ team, we’re pleased to congratulate the Garcia family and wish them well as they start a new adventure in a new home,” Yasin continued.

The company said the drawing illustrates the effectiveness of PERQ’s FATWIN Trade Appraisal Plus solution. Garcia, who had visited multiple dealership websites, landed on the Sawgrass Ford website and was able to quickly go through the interactive Trade Appraisal Plus experience, answer a few questions, and get an estimated trade value for his vehicle.

As part of the process, Garcia entered the sweepstakes — and the rest is history. Now Garcia and family are shopping for a new home, and the dealership has a very happy customer.

“You always see these types of sweepstakes, but you never expect it’s going to be you or your customer that is going to be the beneficiary,” said Rob Baker, Internet sales director at Sawgrass Ford. “It’s a delight that you can put that type of happiness into someone’s life.”

Baker said the entire team at the dealership presented the oversized $25,000 FATWIN check to Garcia and his 8-year-old son.

“The money helps a lot,” Garcia said. “The kids know that this money is going to improve their lives. We are all very happy. I want to thank PERQ and Sawgrass Ford for this opportunity to find a new home.”